Buck Island Reef National Monument
Buck Island was one of the first marine areas in the world given national monument protection, and access is strictly through licensed concession boats out of Christiansted - you cannot simply turn up. The underwater trail runs through a barrier reef of elkhorn coral in a lagoon, with signs on the seabed, and the fish density inside the reef is far beyond anything reachable from a beach. Most trips also stop at Turtle Beach on the island’s west end, a stretch of empty white sand. The crossing takes about half an hour and can be bumpy. Full-day trips include lunch and more swimming time.